Investment Banking » Forums » Applications, Interviews & Assessment Centres » Which offer should I consider taking

Which offer should I consider taking   »   Display all
# 0:56, 19th January 2010 5.00
Hi all, I have been fortunate enough to secure several offers from a number of employers(and a few final interviews), but I can't decide on which one to take. I would like to hear your opinion, and your insights would be much appreciated!

The offers(or finals) : (I'm excluding the names of most employers)
1) hedge fund, distressed desk
2) bulge-bracket bank, equity capital market
3) top consultancy, general financial consulting
4) specialised consultancy(not as famous but has international presence), private equity investment advisory
5) consultancy(ranked 10-20 by vault), pension/investment consulting(actuarial)
6) HSBC international management
7) Boutique PE firm specialising in ultra prime residentials.

Many thanks in advance.
reply   quote

# 9:29, 19th January 2010
Hi, did you attend HSBC assessment center? If yes, can you give me some advice on that?
Thanks
reply   quote

# 10:27, 19th January 2010
i would go for number 1 or 2
reply   quote

# 12:01, 19th January 2010
Hi Wang, I have been invited to their AC, it's a 2day event, with lots of assessments, so anything you can think of will take place there.
reply   quote

# 17:16, 19th January 2010
2>1>3
reply   quote

# 17:18, 19th January 2010
BB grad programs tend to offer more training than hedge funds (I am basing this on two people I know working at hedge funds). If you got all of those offers you probably know a lot more than me anyway!
reply   quote

# 19:19, 19th January 2010
Hi thanks, you are absolutely right about formal trainings. Hedge fund training is on the job, while in a BB bank, there are lots of financial training programmes. Nevertheless, those formal training really teaches you not much about your real job. I'm not too bothered about formal training as I know all the basics (which is what those trainings are for).
reply   quote

# 21:02, 19th January 2010
depends if the hedge funds job is an analyst/trainee trader, or whether you have to work your way up through ops or finance. If you move straight into an FO role I would take the hedge fund
reply   quote

# 11:24, 20th January 2010
I have all the admiration for those who worked their way up through ops/fin in a hedge fund. this is an analyst job though... I yesterday received an offer from a boutique PE firm specialising in ultra prime residential LBOs. errrr
reply   quote

# 23:52, 20th January 2010
Simply depends on what you want to do really... Fair play for getting all these offers but from what I see, you seem a bit confused. There is no direction as to what financial career path you want to follow, and so the only advice that I can offer is for you to go away and study these roles very carefully and see which ones match your career goals. Personally, I'll go for BB then hedge fund and then any other front office roles, especially if the hedge fund in question isn't a established player. The turnover rate of staff at these funds are quite ridiculous, and if trading strategies go wrong, junior analysts are usually the first out.... My 2 cents!!
reply   quote

# 13:02, 21st January 2010
thx! your comment is much appreciated!
reply   quote

# 23:21, 21st January 2010
Depending on how good the HF and PE are, but assuming all are top class, I'd go for PE>HF>BB.

I have a great interest in real estate, so the PE advice is biased.
reply   quote

# 0:28, 2nd February 2010
Choose the prestige.. e.g. GS > DB but Mckinsey > DB but Moore Capital > McKinsey
reply   quote

# 16:16, 6th February 2010
If this is your first job, I would go for the top-tier IB or consultancy. If not, that is, if you have 3-4 years prior experience, I would go for the HF job. The HF industry is essentially a call option on the rest of the economy, so even if you do end up losing your job because a trading strategy goes wrong, you would still be employable with prior experience. I would take a daring stance and agree with Doloris that prestige-seeking is a more reasonable strategy for a fresh grad.
reply   quote

Apologies, but you are either not signed in or you don't have a Nicube account. Please sign in or register if you would like to reply to this topic.